Source: Google Images |
Bill C-23, also known as the
Fair Elections Act, is being
proposed as part of the Conservative government's new elections act in
Canada. There are several provisions included in the proposed act and one of
these would make
it more difficult for Elections
Canada to experiment with online voting and other electronic voting
technologies. With the current law, alternative voting methods can be tested as
long as the chief electoral officer gains the approval of the parliamentary
committees that oversee elections.
If the Fair Elections Act is
approved and goes into law, however, then these tests would first need to gain
the approval of both the House of Commons and the Senate. Given that the
Conservative Party of Canada currently has control of the Senate, they could
presumably refuse to authorize any tests for online voting that are put forth
by Elections Canada.
The reason why this Act is
self-serving, according to NDP Democratic Reform critic
Craig Scott is that “e-voting is something [the Conservatives] know
appeals to younger generations, which is not necessarily their voting cohort.”
While not always true, it is
generally understood that younger demographics are the ones that are more
likely to gravitate to and embrace voting technologies, while older generations
are more likely to prefer more traditional methods. As it stands, older
generations are also more likely to vote Conservative than their younger
counterparts. If a larger number of youth voters cast their ballots, the
elections could swing away from the Conservative Party.
The only way that electronic
voting and online voting can move forward in Canada is if Elections Canada is
granted the ability to conduct pilot projects to test out these technologies.
By adding another layer of bureaucracy, one in which the Conservatives would
first have to give their stamp of approval, they could be stifling progress in
the country. This is particularly troublesome when you consider that members of
the Senate are not elected, but are actually appointed.
Even beyond online voting and
electronic voting, the Fair Elections Act proposal could also limit the ability
for students
to vote at the polls, because it would place more stringent restrictions on
the current vouching system in Canada. The same is true for several other
demographics, like minority voters and low-income families, who may not be able
to qualify for traditional eligibility, but should still have every right to
vote.
As it stands, Canada has
already stopped any plans of an Internet voting pilot program in 2015,
further impeding progress in the country to modernize its electoral system and
bring it in line with current technology. If passed, the Fair Elections Act
will make it more difficult than ever to evolve from the archaic manual,
paper-based system for casting ballots.